State Police Row: Constitutional Lawyer Heads to Court to Challenge National Assembly Over Amendment

TAIBAT UMMI YAKUBUThe constitutional amendment paving the way for the establishment of state police in Nigeria is facing a fresh legal challenge, with the Abuja School of Social and Political…

Sulaiman Umar November 19, 2026  ·  12:00 AM
| 38 Views
State Police Row: Constitutional Lawyer Heads to Court to Challenge National Assembly Over Amendment
State Police Row: Constitutional Lawyer Heads to Court to Challenge National Assembly Over Amendment

TAIBAT UMMI YAKUBU


The constitutional amendment paving the way for the establishment of state police in Nigeria is facing a fresh legal challenge, with the Abuja School of Social and Political Thoughts threatening to have the entire process declared invalid over alleged violations by the House of Representatives.

The organisation's Director, Dr Sam Amadi, said it would return to court on December 10 to seek an order nullifying the amendment, arguing that the National Assembly failed to follow the constitutional procedures required to alter the country's supreme law.

Amadi, a constitutional lawyer, disclosed this on Thursday while addressing journalists in Abuja, alleging that although the Senate followed the prescribed voting procedure, the House of Representatives did not secure the amendment through the constitutionally required process.

He maintained that lawmakers could not rely on their legislative authority to amend the Constitution while disregarding the procedures specifically provided for such changes.

“The Senate voted properly; the House did not vote properly. As a constitutional lawyer and teacher, I know that although the National Assembly has the right to make laws, it cannot make laws except in accordance with the constitution,” he said.

To support his argument, Amadi referred to a Supreme Court decision that invalidated an appropriation law despite presidential assent because the required concurrence between the two chambers of the National Assembly had not been obtained.

He argued that constitutional amendments must satisfy the same principle of strict compliance with prescribed procedures, warning that allowing lawmakers to bypass those requirements would undermine the authority of the Constitution and the rights of citizens.

“The constitution has told you how you can amend it. You cannot amend the constitution except as the constitution has prescribed. Otherwise, you are taking over the power of the people,” he said.

Amadi explained that his organisation had already initiated legal proceedings over the matter, but the case had twice failed to proceed to hearing because of the court's crowded schedule and the attention being given to pre-election matters.

He said the December 10 hearing would provide an opportunity to amend the reliefs being sought to specifically request the invalidation of the state police amendment, which has already received the necessary legislative approvals and presidential assent.

Beyond the immediate challenge, the organisation is pursuing another case seeking a general judicial pronouncement that would compel the National Assembly to observe constitutional requirements whenever it undertakes future amendments.

Advertisement

NRS Gateway

Amadi also criticised opposition parties and elected lawmakers for failing to challenge what he described as procedural violations, arguing that political representatives had a responsibility to defend the Constitution rather than remain silent for fear of becoming targets.

“I blame the opposition and those elected to represent their constituencies who stay silent because they do not want to be targeted,” he said.

However, he was quick to clarify that his organisation's legal action should not be interpreted as opposition to the creation of state police.

He said the School had been involved in conversations about decentralising Nigeria's policing system for years, but argued that the central problem went beyond whether policing should be controlled by federal or state authorities.

Amadi said he was neither an advocate of an exclusively federal police structure nor an uncritical supporter of state-controlled policing, insisting that the politicisation of security institutions was the more fundamental challenge.

“Neither the president nor the governor should control police operations. Policing should be a professional responsibility, not an instrument of political authority,” he said.

He proposed a policing arrangement involving federal, state and local government formations, with clearly separated responsibilities and operational independence to prevent political interference.

The constitutional lawyer also warned against rushing the implementation of state police without first resolving major practical questions, including funding, recruitment, personnel training, infrastructure and the future of officers currently serving in the Nigeria Police Force.

He said the relationship between federal and state police formations would also need to be clearly defined to prevent jurisdictional disputes, institutional rivalry and confusion over operational responsibilities.

The planned court challenge could therefore introduce another legal dimension to the debate over police decentralisation in Nigeria, shifting attention from the merits of establishing state police to whether the constitutional process used to approve the amendment was legally valid.

Written by

Sulaiman Umar

Sulaiman Umar is an editor and reporter with extensive experience in economic journalism, analyzing financial and agricultural developments in Northern Nigeria.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Leave a Comment

What is 5 + 4?